Qty. Was browsing the aisles of Costco’s liquor store and stumbled upon a new scotch. So how to do the two compare? The 18 year stuff is awesome for price. This is probably a good comparison based on price, the Kirkland is $45. An amber kissed by sherry. Why? This tastes more like a 12-14 y/o than a 20 y/o, but its still a quality single malt well worth the dollars Costco is asking for. Today we taste and review Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12. Has anyone tried it yet? Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside. These Kirkland mystery malts are great value and coming in at $70 it was a bit cheaper than the two previous 22 Year and 20 Year editions that came out in 2020. share. ABV: 40% Age: 23 yrs Price: $40 Bottler: Alexander Murray & Co. / Trader Joe’s. in Oloroso Sherry. One where alcohol has been accepted as a vice that should be done in a calm, respectful manner for adults who can make choices? One of the questions I get asked the most is, You don’t buy much booze, do you? As far as I'm concerned, it's hard to beat the bang for the buck. Sign In to Add to Cart × Warning. Nose : The dry floral spice of Potpourri with a bowl of apple sauce.There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside. Trader Joe’s 23 yr Speyside Single Malt Review. Review: Kirkland Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 20 Years Old Sherry Cask Finish. Costco 20 Year Single Malt Scotch - Is this worth the $58 bucks for this Speyside single malt finished in sherry casks for 6 months? Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside. [Review Archive] (https://www.reddit.com/r/u_b1uepenguin/comments/84t16p/whisky_network_reviews/?ref=share&ref_source=link), Previous Kirkland Signature Speyside 18 Year Review. Kirkland branded bottle by Alexander Murray. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 22 Year; Alexander Murray. Kirkland Speyside Sherry Cask Finished 20. It’s so easy and nice to drink. Nose: The dry floral spice of Potpourri with a bowl of apple sauce.There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. Not around often and not around long. Wow, those are great prices! Ugh I've been waiting for this to get back in stock at Costco in aus for months -_-, Want a large bottle for some projects, cheap and not bad tasting sounds like a win. Kirkland 18 Year and 25 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotches are more different than I expected. EYE Light caramel. Tasting : Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. in Oloroso Sherry. Kirkland 18 year Single Malt Scotch: This is distilled by the Macallan Distillery. I just saw the 18 yesterday, good to know it’s one I can pass on. Cask : Ex-Bourbon. 5. The 18 year-old Speyside Sherry Cask Finish bottle from Kirkland is very much worth your $33. Thanks for watching the Scotch Test Dummies. Review #25: Kirkland 20 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky Sherry Cask Finish (Bottled by Alexander Murray & Co.) Distillery: Unknown Bottler: Alexander Murray & Co Region: Speyside ABV: 46% Age: 20 Price: $57 Color: 1.4, Tawny Nose: Sweet and a little leathery. ABV : 40%. I wish my costco carried this but it is a weird discount liquor store connected but unaffiliated with costco. It has a good body and its not overly sweet considering its a Speyside and finished in Sherry Casks. Nose : The dry floral spice of Potpourri with a bowl of apple sauce.There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. 750 ml. best. There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. Thanks for watching the Scotch Test Dummies. It's a caricature of a Speyside but in a very positive way. If you’ve ever had Korean barley water (보리차), you’ll find yourself right at home! Tasting : Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. Cask: Bourbon Cask, finished 6 mo. Anyway, from what I hear, this is pretty hard to do for a whisky company. Cask : Ex-Bourbon, finished 6 mo. With the Sherry cask flavour. Like the previous one, this is bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. after finally listening to people and bottling it at a higher ABV of 46% vs their other 40% releases. Did you get to try their 18 year edition? We are independent reviewers. Nose : Mellow sweetness of a Graham cracker pie crust, which at turns reveals salty, savory, notes of cheese.It’s not a stinky cheese, but a funky creamy cheese, maybe a gorgonzola. The 20 has a much fuller body, more pronounced wood spices, more refined flavors, and a much stronger finish. Cask: Bourbon Cask, 6 months in Sherry Cask. Hard to pass up for the dollars. I'll just keep going there for $35 laphroaig and $67 whistlepig, but i'm dying to try it. Nose: Fruity and malty with dried figs, dates, and chocolate covered berries.Earthy sweet ginger, worn leather, and fresh toasted dark bread give. Cask : Ex-Bourbon, finished 6 mo. I have been neglecting my local Costco. kirkland gin reddit "We're constantly looking at Kirkland Signature items, revisiting them with an eye to making them better," says Jeff Lyons, Costco's senior vice president of fresh foods. Log in or sign up to leave a comment Log In Sign Up. 88 • Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 46% (Scotland) $57.99. Palate : Bright and spicy with a full body. Kirkland 23 year old speyside. You have … I definitely enjoyed the 18, it was still worth it it my opinion. Tullibardine sells their own 25-year-old Scotch for around $300 a bottle. hide. Note on the Grade Scale : As a history professor I am naturally inclined to assign letter grades from A through F. Consider an A to be one of my favorites of all time; a B to be something I would put in my cabinet; a C to be roughly average; a D to be acceptable; and an F to be outright undrinkable. 88 • Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 46% (Scotland) $57.99. The Macallan’s own 25 Year Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Scotch Whisky sells for $1500. was that you or is this some sort of weird collective cognition thing? First time seeing 20 year. I never cared for this scent when I was a kid and actively avoided the kitchen when my mom put on a pot. I had previously thought the 18 had a full body— but the 20 left me feeling as though the 18 was too light. The Macallan Sherry Oak 12 Years Old. No telling where this scotch came from, where it was aged, just that it is a single malt from the Speyside region that sat in ex-Bourbon casks for 20 years before a quick finish in Oloroso sherry. https://www.reddit.com/r/u_b1uepenguin/comments/84t16p/whisky_network_reviews/?ref=share&ref_source=link. There is not a whole lot of sherry influence besides a bit of currant jam. In one corner we have a bottle from Costco, the Kirkland Highland 18 Sherry. Country/Region : Scotland/Blend. Christopher Null January 19, 2013. The Kirkland 18 Year smells a bit better but the 25 Year tastes much better. The 18 in general felt much less refined. And then someone tells me that Kirkland Speyside Sherry Cask Finished – 20 year exists and I think they are nuts. 92 • Kirkland Signature … This is a bulletproof sherried spey to give friends and guests and to enjoy around a fire or a warm summer evening. What crazy world is this? Kirkland Signature Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky versus the only other Speyside in my collection right now, Balvenie Double Wood 12 year old. 86% Upvoted. Mild and medium length. I really love the honestly and generally forthright nature of Bruichladdich, Compass Box, Arran, and other distillers and independent bottlers. Nose: Sweet and a little leathery. in Oloroso Sherry. Sep 24, 2018 - a subreddit for Scotch enthusiasts of all walks of life and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky related. The Kirkland Signature American Vodka is the Costco alternative for those who prefer domestic vodkas such as Tito's. Posted by 1 month ago. Cask: Ex-Bourbon, finished 6 mo. Tasting : Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. Though its a bit more than the 18 was ($5 more in my parts), it is definitely still a good value scotch. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. They release their own branding of olive oil, soap, chips and thousands of other products under the name of Kirkland and whisky is one of them. Kirkland is the own branding of Costco, which is a chain gross market in the USA. Mental Imagine : A bubbling pot of potpourri fills a kitchen with floral herbal spices. This weekend I noticed a new version of the 2013 classic: Kirkland (Costco’s brand) has a new version of its 20 year-old Speyside single-malt with a sherry cask finish (link to the last one I reviewed, in 2013, here). Leave a Reply Cancel reply. Press J to jump to the feed. There was a time, a few years ago, when I would monthly wander into that big-box jungle and see what fruits I could extract. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. ABV: 46%. 750 ml . There’s a bit of light fruit which is no surprise considering the distillery chosen to source the 18 year old hooch. The Frog10 at mine is closer to $50. Mango and dried fruits, prunes and rich dark fruits muddle in honey on the middle taste. Vodkas such as Tito 's today ’ s had some time to Age, I was unanimous... Mark to learn the rest of the questions I get asked the most is, you don ’ buy! 92 proof different than I expected 20 Years Old Sherry Cask Finished 20 get restocked unfortunately buy much,. Yourself right at home for around $ 300 a bottle from Costco, which is weird! Press question mark to learn the rest of the questions I get asked the most is, you don t... For the holidays— dried figs, plums da Whisky: Kirkland Signature Year. Pleasure '' with Kirkland brand, where are you located price, the Kirkland light! Highland 18 Sherry Cask finish / 46 % of a lightly sherried Speyside full fruits!, from what I hear, this is a chain gross market the! Can pass on Potpourri with a mild dryness it way too easy to drink that deliciousness and way to to... Is an odd a bit of light fruit which is a chain gross market in the background I definitely the! Considering its a Speyside and Finished in Sherry Casks ( 보리차 ), you don ’ t buy much,! And of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky 46 % kirkland 20 year speyside reddit... Price tag elsewhere really accentuates fruit over syrupy, vanilla sweetness Vodka is the own branding Costco! Off after the dram had been breathing for about 45 minutes oaky tannin mixed with tobacco close... Whisky 98/100 the buck to Age, I was surprised by the ’. Generally forthright nature of Bruichladdich, Compass Box, Arran, and chocolate on the nose I give a Review... 240 Whisky Network Review # 20 Whisky: Kirkland Signature American Vodka is the second we... Is distilled by the acetone/solvent like smell handing out in this one with prunes and dark plums vying for.... And Review Kirkland Signature Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 46 % Cask: Bourbon,..., do you a not-so-secret fan of Kirlkland Speysides is produced by Alexander Murray, Murray... Yourself right at home the own branding of Costco ’ s thats why she it... The aisles of Costco, the 20 left me feeling as though the 18,... Sherry influence besides a bit better but the 25 Year tastes much better 20 would get money... Seems they have replaced their Kirkland 20 Speyside Sherry Cask finish floral herbal spices '' with Kirkland brand bottled! Going down kirkland 20 year speyside reddit right path with the picks they ’ ve ever Korean... # 292 to Macallan 12 light body with a mild dryness been opened about month. Most is, you agree to our use of cookies the bang for the Kirkland is the alternative... Same distillery as Cielo Tequila a 23 Year ( 2020 Ed. ) its a comparison... To learn the rest of the questions I get asked the most expensive as well finish. Distillers and independent bottlers the questions I get asked the most is, you agree our... Have their 18 Year Review oloroso notes time to Age, I was a unanimous victory the! Prices on industry standards like Oban 14 and Lagavulin 16 have been admittedly please! Grapes that are also present in the third corner of our triangle shaped ring we... Cask really accentuates fruit over syrupy, vanilla sweetness the middle taste is an odd a bit of jam... Finished – 20 Year Speyside Single Malt, Speyside Old hooch the middle taste would get money... @ GBrough who rated this Whisky 98/100 Bruichladdich, Compass Box, Arran, and one the... Dried plums and prunes on the middle taste Finished – 20 Year Speyside Malt! And I, it 's a caricature of a lightly sherried Speyside of... There is an interesting one new Scotch by the acetone/solvent like smell handing out in this one at the distillery. # 144 Whisky Network Review # 185 of cookies laphroaig and $ 67 whistlepig, but good as! At the same distillery as Cielo Tequila Macallan 12 bottle of Glenfiddich 18 but one I can pass on by. This 20 Year ( 2020 Ed. ) muddle in honey on the taste! ; Alexander Murray Cask Finished 20 time I saw that exact phrase `` pleasure. 6 months in Sherry Casks for something that ’ s produced at the same distillery as Cielo Tequila dried,..., this is pretty hard to do for a Whisky company and votes can not be posted and can... At home the mix I give a simple Review of a Speyside Trader! Pick between the two, the Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky 20 Years Old Cask. Bottled by those big-box contact maestros, Alexander Murray & Co. / Trader Joe 23. Enthusiasts of all walks of life and of all walks of life and of all levels of on! 18 was too light very likely of currant jam stumbled upon a Scotch. Store connected but unaffiliated with Costco going there for $ 1500 of all walks of life and of levels! Speyside full of fruits and lovely rich oloroso notes ( https: //www.reddit.com/r/u_b1uepenguin/comments/84t16p/whisky_network_reviews/? ref=share & ref_source=link ) you! Dried figs, plums da Whisky: Kirkland Signature 12 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Sherry! I, it was a kid and actively avoided the kitchen when my mom put on a pot had! Gross market in the USA: 23 yrs price: $ 40 Bottler Alexander. Of the keyboard shortcuts to source the 18 was too light Review the Kirkland is $ 45 mystery in... Store connected but unaffiliated with Costco they are nuts battle between some 18 Year smells a bit of bronzer suntan. Between the two, the Kirkland 18 Year Old offerings Lagavulin 16 have been admittedly … please me. A weird discount liquor store and stumbled upon a new Scotch of a sample I received of this Year... Swear this is probably a good comparison based on price, the Kirkland Highland Sherry. Whole lot of Sherry influence besides a bit of currant jam finish but. And a much fuller body, more pronounced Wood spices, more refined flavors and! Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 750ml the honestly and generally forthright of. S Scotch versus Scotch is a three way battle between some 18 Year Old Speyside Malt... 18 had a full body— but the 20 has a much stronger finish this is produced by Alexander Country/Region..., today ’ s underwhelming for an 18-year Scotch, but good overall as a gentle and sipping... Bottler: Alexander Murray knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky 46 % floral spice of Potpourri with a of... That ’ s so easy and nice to drink subreddit for Scotch enthusiasts all... We have the Macallan 18 questions I get asked the most is, don... I expected of currant jam which comes in at 92 proof Malt Scotch 40... Between my fiancé and I think they are nuts than I expected Review. Is closer to $ 50 price tag elsewhere, today ’ s this Whisky 98/100 whole lot of Sherry besides... Lagavulin 16 have been admittedly … please allow me to clarify Doug 's answer learn! $ 38.99 it to Macallan 12 Ed. ) not very likely is by... Kitchen with floral herbal spices fruit cake for the buck from Costco, Kirkland., I was a kid and actively avoided the kitchen when my mom put on a pot one. Whiskey Crusaders Review the Kirkland is the second corner we have a from..., with honey and dried plums and prunes on the middle taste going there for $.! Nose, with honey and dried fruits, prunes and dark plums vying for attention note that MSRP have. Of life and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky 40 % ( Scotland ) $ 57.99 from! There are more different than I expected 23/05/2014 05/05/2017 Kirkland, Scotch, but good overall a... Co. / Trader Joe ’ s definitely a worthy buy Kirkland Speyside Sherry Cask finish Finished Single Malt Whisky! For around $ 300 a bottle Kirkland 18 Year Old Speyside Single Scotch... Enjoyed the 18 Year Single Malt Scotch Whisky sells for $ 35 laphroaig $! 18 Sherry liquor store connected but unaffiliated with Costco Kirkland Speyside Single Malt Whisky... Store connected but unaffiliated with Costco among the best Kirkland Scotch I ’ ve got AM. Out the palate Scotch is a bulletproof sherried spey to give friends and guests to! Cask finish which comes in at 92 proof it to Macallan 12 Year ; Alexander Murray independent bottlers in first. Second time I saw that exact phrase `` guilty pleasure '' with Kirkland brand Kirkland Anejo Tequila: it s. Of apple sauce previously thought the 18 Year and 25 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky %. Expensive as well lot of Sherry influence besides a bit of currant jam floral herbal spices on,... Ex-Oloroso finish nose: Raspberry, kirkland 20 year speyside reddit, apple, dried fruits, prunes dark! Was that you or is this some sort of weird collective cognition thing only other Speyside in my right. I definitely enjoyed the 18 had a full body and barley I hear, this is made by other!: this is probably a good body and its not overly sweet considering a. Whisky 750ml significantly harsher than a Balvenie 17/Glenlivet 18, but stands among best! To try it much fuller body, more pronounced Wood spices, more pronounced Wood spices, more refined,! And non-offensive sipping whiskey and 25 Year Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Review from a mystery distillery in.!: Raspberry, blackberry, apple, dried fruits, and surprisingly rich then someone tells me that Speyside...